Short answer
Hire a roofer who is licensed where your state requires it, carries liability and workers' comp insurance, gives a detailed written estimate, pulls the permit, and explains both the material and workmanship warranties.

Know what you need before you call
Roofers quote more accurately when you can describe the job: an active leak, storm damage, an aging roof near replacement, or just an inspection. If you're not sure, say so — a reputable roofer starts with an inspection and explains what they find. Knowing whether you need repair, replacement or an inspection keeps the conversation focused.
Check the basics
These protect you if something goes wrong.
- License or registration where your state requires it (see your state page)
- Certificates of liability and workers' comp insurance
- A local address and references
- A physical local office or yard you could visit — not just a PO box and a cell number
- Proof of workers' comp in particular: if a worker is hurt on your property and the company has no coverage, the liability can land on you
- A written estimate listing tear-off, decking, underlayment, flashing and ventilation
What a good written estimate lists
Vague one-line quotes make fair comparison impossible. A proper estimate spells out:
- Tear-off of old roofing — how many layers — and disposal
- Decking replacement terms: what's included per sheet and what costs extra
- Underlayment type, ice-and-water shield locations, and flashing replacement at chimneys, valleys and vents
- Ventilation plan — intake and exhaust, not just 'new vents'
- Cleanup, landscaping protection and a magnet sweep for nails
- Start date, expected duration, payment schedule and warranty terms
Comparing bids fairly
Get two or three estimates and line them up item by item. A bid that's dramatically cheaper usually leaves something out — thinner underlayment, reusing old flashing, skipping ventilation work, or no workmanship warranty. Ask each roofer what the others included that they didn't, and watch how they answer.
Warranties
Two warranties matter. The manufacturer covers material defects — typically 20 to 50 years depending on the product, though proration and fine print vary. The contractor covers installation errors — this is the one that actually gets used, and it only lasts as long as the company stays in business. Get both in writing, and ask what voids them: inadequate ventilation and pressure washing are common exclusions.
The contract and payment
Everything agreed goes in the written contract: scope, materials by brand and product line, price, start and completion dates, cleanup, and warranty terms. Deposits are normal — often around a third or less of the job — but never pay in full before the work is done. Hold the final payment until you've walked the property, checked the cleanup, and received the warranty paperwork and final invoice.
Insurance-claim jobs: special care
After storm damage, the roofer and the insurance adjuster each write a scope, and they don't always agree. A good contractor attends the adjuster meeting, documents everything with photos, and files supplements for items the estimate missed. Be wary of anyone who asks you to sign over your claim benefits or promises to handle everything without explaining what you're signing. See filing a roof insurance claim.
Red flags
Walk away from contractors who show these:
- Large upfront deposits or demands for full payment before work starts
- Pressure to sign the same day, especially after a storm
- Offers to pay, waive or rebate your insurance deductible — illegal in some states
- Contracts that hand your insurance claim to the contractor without a clear explanation
- No local address, no proof of insurance, or unwillingness to pull a permit
Questions
How many estimates should I get?
Two or three is common, making sure each covers the same scope.
Who pulls the permit?
Usually the licensed contractor. Ask to see it.
Should I take the cheapest bid?
Not automatically. Compare what's included line by line — the cheapest bid often skips flashing replacement, proper ventilation or a workmanship warranty. The best value is the bid with the fullest scope at a fair price, from a contractor who will still be around in five years.
What does a contractor's workmanship warranty actually cover?
Installation mistakes: leaks from poorly installed flashing, shingles or vents. It doesn't cover storm damage, normal wear or manufacturer defects. Ask how long it lasts, whether it's in writing, and who honors it if the company closes.
How much should I pay upfront?
A modest deposit to cover materials is normal. Be cautious of anyone demanding most or all of the money before the crew arrives. Tie payments to milestones, and keep the final payment until the job passes your walkthrough.
How can I check a roofer's insurance myself?
Ask for the certificate of insurance and call the insurer listed on it to confirm the policy is current. Certificates can be faked or expired, so the phone call is the check that matters.
This guide is general information, not professional, legal or insurance advice. Follow your insurer's instructions and local codes, and put safety first.